December 9, 2011
My Book of 2011: Into the Silence by Wade Davis
As a critic, you encounter all kinds of books. Some are just awful. Some are worthy, but dull. A few are good; some books even entertain. Then there are books you live in. (They don’t come along very often.) Into the Silence: The Great War, Mallory, and the Conquest of Everest is one of those kind of books. As thrilling as any adventure story, and grounded in awe-inspiring research, this magnificent account of the British Everest expeditions of the 1920s and the doomed attempts of George Mallory to scale the world’s tallest mountain is one of the best books I have ever reviewed.
June 9, 2011
Bobby Fischer Against the World
HBO’s new documentary perfectly captures the pathos and ugliness of one of chess’s all-time greats. It’s a fine compliment to Frank Brady’s new Fischer bio, which I reviewed earlier this year in The Boston Globe.
September 24, 2010
The TLS and the British Spy
In a fascinating piece about the relationship between two quintessential British institutions—the Times Literary Supplement and spying—the historian Keith Jeffery looks at how various TLS hands reviewed spy fiction and memoirs, genres which emerged in the years after WWI. Not surprisingly, the British Secret Intelligence Service was none too happy when ex-employees wanted to tell their story. But there was often not much to tell—Somerset Maugham, who worked as spy during the war, observed that the work of an agent was “on the whole extremely monotonous,” and produced much that was “uncommonly useless.” Maugham’s fictionalized versions of his experiences, which he collected in his Ashenden tales, hardly compare to the over the top action of Ian Fleming’s 007 novels. Indeed, the TLS reviewer, praising Maugham with faint damns, concluded that his work was “only moderately entertaining.”
Then there was the paranoid former Chief of Secret Service who outlined his memoir thus: “The book will be quarto size, bound in red, top-edge gilt, subtitled ‘The Indiscretions of the CSS.’ It will have four hundred pages, all blank.”
September 23, 2010
Wodehouse and Psmith
P.G. Wodehouse is best known for his creations Jeeves and Wooster, yet, as D.J. Taylor writes in a recent issue of the TLS, Wodehouse forged his reputation on the adventures of Ronald (formerly Rupert) Psmith, a “supercharged, upper-class version of the “masher” or “knut” of the Edwardian comic paper.”
September 23, 2010
Happy Birthday, Penguin
Penguin Books is celebrating its 75th birthday this year. Here’s a piece I wrote in 2006 about Penguin founder Allen Lane, and the enduring genius of his imprint’s always eye-catching designs. (The look of this website is an homage to Penguin’s classic orange and black livery).
September 22, 2010
Marguerite Duras on Writing
Back after a very long break with this beautiful passage from Marguerite Duras. Few observations about writing match this one for its force and insight.
“In life there comes a moment, and I believe that it’s unavoidable, that one cannot escape it, when everything is put in doubt: marriage, friends, especially friends of the couple. Not children. Children are never put in doubt. And this doubt grows around one. This doubt is alone, it is the doubt of solitude. It is born of solitude. We can already speak the word. I believe that most people couldn’t stand what I’m saying here, that they’d run away from it. This might be the reason why everyone is not a writer. Yes. That’s the difference. That is the truth. No other. Doubt equals writing. So it also equals the writer.”
March 25, 2009
George Scialabba: A Model Critic
Years ago, when I first started reading the quality literary and political reviews, I kept coming across the name George Scialabba. As I quickly discovered, his essays and reviews were thought provoking and sharply turned. Since then, George has been a model. I can’t say that I share his fondness for the likes of Noam Chomksy, but Scialabba is a member of no party or faction. Like one of his (and my) heroes Irving Howe, George is a social democrat with an independent streak.
“What Are Intellectuals Good For?” (Pressed Wafer, $15) collects almost twenty years worth of Scialabba’s stuff, and there is much here to relish: a bracingly unreverential look at Edward Said (two cheers for that), and a devastating appraisal of Christopher Hitchens, to name just two notable pieces. Scott McLemee, another model man of letters, provides a very fine introduction. I’ll keep this anthology close to hand.
July 16, 2008
A Few Killer Theories
I just got my hands on an advance copy of Library of America’s forthcoming “True Crime: An American Anthology,” which I will be writing about at length in the fall. Included is a piece by Jack Webb on one of America’s most famous crimes, the 1947 murder of Elizabeth Short—aka the Black Dahlia—whose whose mutilated body was found in a abandoned lot in LA’s Leimert Park neighborhood. Unsolved to this day, Short’s murder has inspired a lot of crackpot theories about her killer’s identity—someone even fingered Orson Welles as a suspect. Advances in forensic technology have brought us no closer to a solution; the Dahlia killer remains in the shadows, just out of reach, a constant incitement for wild speculation and a lot of factually dubious funny business.
You could say the same thing about one of history’s other elusive killers, Jack the Ripper. Who was he? Everyone from Lewis Carroll to the Duke of Clarence has been named as a suspect. A few years ago, the mystery writer Patricia Cornwell made a complete fool out of herself trying to prove that British painter Walter Sickert was the real Ripper. Not a chance. More recently, in his utterly fascinating book “The Fox and the Flies: The World of Joseph Silver, Racketeer and Psychopath,” the South African historian Charles van Onselen advanced the notion that the Polish-born Silver, a police informant and small-time hood, was the Ripper. Van Onselen doesn’t quite prove his case—much of his evidence is circumstantial—but his research into the late 19th century underworld is staggering. The book didn’t attract much attention, but was the subject of a very fine piece earlier this year by the English writer Charles Nicholl.
RECENT BLOG POSTS
April 21, 2015
Oh yea, and big city dailies continue to roll of the presses….
April 21, 2015
‘They Can Live in the Desert but Nowhere Else’
The evidence is indisputable, argues David Gardner: the great catastrophe that befell…
April 20, 2015
The Corporation with its own Army
Imagine ExxonMobil with a 260,000 man military force at its disposal. Such…
April 18, 2015
Farewell to Harry Eyres
For the last ten years, Harry Eyres’ Slow Lane column has graced…
May 25, 2012
The Death of the Metro Daily, Con’t
Several years ago, I laid odds on what big American city would…
See all recent blog posts »
SELECTED ARTICLES BY
Stalin: The Paradoxes of Power
The National, November 6, 2014
Hitler's First Victims
The Boston Globe, October 25, 2014
Midnight at the Pera Palace: Istanbul Between the Wars
The National, October 9, 2014
Rebel Yell: The Life of Stonewall Jackson
Newsday, September 30, 2014
When The United States Spoke French
The Boston Globe, August 16, 2014
See all posted articles »
J. Peder Zane