Matthew Price, writer and book critic
Matthew Price's Blog

Category: Sports

Check out The Arrogant Ball on Twitter



Posted By

Matthew Price

URL

Permalink

Categories

Sports

Pete Rose Deserves Fame

There was a controversial guest on HBO’s Costas Now town hall meeting on the state of baseball in 2008. He’s one of the most notorious players in the history of the game—no, it wasn’t Barry Bonds, but all-time hits leader Pete Rose. Major League Baseball wants nothing to do with Rose, an incredibly flawed man whose gambling habit—he bet on games when he managed the Cincinnati Reds back in eighties—earned him a lifetime ban from the game. Rose, interestingly enough, appeared on a segment called “The Hall of Fame: What Gets You In?” This is a pretty darn good question these days, with steroids-era sluggers like Mark McGwire up for eligibility, and a profusion of newfangled stats that, if anything, has made judging a player’s performance harder, not easier.

Alluding to the scandal plagued McGwire, Rose, and Bonds, Hall of Fame third baseman Mike Schmidt observed there is no player in the Hall without sin. It was a politic comment, but not a disingenuous one, I think. Even if Hall voters are asked to weigh a player’s integrity, the Hall isn’t about virtue. There’s a sliding scale when it comes to integrity, but the line has to be drawn somewhere. Rose broke an explicit rule—no gambling—but is this worse than taking performance enhancing drugs? Rose’s betting habit didn’t help his players hit the ball harder. It’s a tough call, but Charlie Hustle deserves reinstatement, and a place in the Hall of Fame.


Posted By

Matthew Price

URL

Permalink

Categories

Sports

BLOG CATEGORIES

Books
History
Ideas
Miscellany
News
Newspapers
Sports
Television
Travel

RECENT BLOG POSTS

The Death of the Metro Daily, Con’t
Several years ago, I waggishly laid odds on what big American city…

My Book of 2011: Into the Silence by Wade Davis
As a critic, you encounter all kinds of books. Some are just…

Critics: A Wretched Species?
Two cheers for the critic! Superannuated (perhaps, but still hanging on by…

Bobby Fischer Against the World
HBO’s new documentary perfectly captures the pathos and ugliness of one of…

What bin Laden Cost Us
National Journal has just published a fine and deeply depressing piece…

See all recent blog posts »

SELECTED ARTICLES BY
MATTHEW PRICE

The Wine Savant; Or Why You Shouldn't Settle for Two Buck Chuck
The Boston Globe, December 21, 2013

Servants: A Downstairs History of Britain
Newsday , December 8, 2013

Bertie: The Life of King Edward VII
The Boston Globe, December 7, 2013

Joe Sacco's "The Great War"
The National, November 28, 2013

1914-2014: The First World War, One Hundred Years On
The National , November 28, 2013

See all posted articles »

KINDRED SPIRITS

BookDaddy
Caleb Crain
Critical Mass
Elegant Variation
Howard French
Andrew Hearst
Jacket Copy
Scott McLemee
Maud Newton
Carlin Romano
Chris Rose
Slipped Disc
J. Peder Zane

Matthew Price, writer and book critic


SITE DESIGN

Andrew Hearst